Arizona’s Battle For Water

Arizona’s Battle For Water

Arizona’s water crisis is no longer just a warning about the future.

Record-low water levels at Lake Mead and Lake Powell, and new federal cuts, are forcing hard choices for farmers, cities, and the states that share the Colorado River.

Scott Thuman reports from Arizona.

Transcript:

In Arizona’s Casa Grande Valley, it’s hot and dusty. These fields shouldn’t be bare, but there’s no water to grow crops this year across much of Nancy Caywood’s family farm.

Scott: How does it make you feel when you look at this?

Nancy Caywood: It makes me want to cry. I mean, it’s very sad to know that my grandfather toiled for this, my dad and my son, and now we can’t do anything with it.

The channels they rely on to water the 250-acre farm are instead littered with tumbleweed.

Scott: How do you describe for someone who has no idea what that would be like to say that you haven’t had any water since last March, what does that mean?

Nancy Caywood: Well, it means we can’t plant anything. We can’t grow anything.

Farmers are blaming decades of drought, record-low snowpack and hotter temperatures – combined with expanding cities and tech industries.

Central to the crisis is the Colorado River — running 1,400 miles from the Rockies through Arizona and on to Mexico. It irrigates five million acres of farmland, and 40 million people rely on it for some or all of their water. The Colorado provides Scottsdale with 70 percent of its water.

But the river and its reservoirs are under severe strain.

At Lake Powell, and here at Lake Mead in Nevada, water levels are at record lows – which is also creating power problems.

Scott: At full capacity, the Hoover Dam generates enough electricity to power more than a million homes, but as Lake Mead’s levels drop, so does the power. Right now it’s down by more than thirty percent.

Meanwhile, downstream, water demand is growing as the population does too.

Rhett Larson: I’ve spent my career as kind of the optimist trying to tell people to calm down, that solutions are coming, and I’ve spent the last couple of years telling people it’s time to get really worried.

Rhett Larson is a water law professor at Arizona State University and an expert on how Colorado River water is divided between the states.

Rhett Larson: For the foreseeable future, it won’t look like taps running dry, but it will look like higher water rates. And my constant refrain to people is we are not running out of water. We are running out of cheap water.

No single state owns the river. Its water is divided under a patchwork of agreements, federal laws, treaties, and court decisions dating back to 1922. The seven basin states negotiated the Colorado River Compact, with the federal government, dividing water between the upper and lower basins—using river-flow estimates from an unusually wet period.

Rhett Larson: So we bankrupted the river the minute we created the law. And the reason was that 1922 was a flood year, and we were using all of the data during high-flow years. So we made bad math assumptions in 1922, and we’re paying the price.

Now, with states squaring off over low reservoirs, the federal government is mandating cuts, and Arizona is set to lose 27 percent of its normal Colorado River allocation next year.

Arizona has joined Nevada in challenging the plan. Larson says a long court fight could make matters worse.

Rhett Larson: If litigation bogs down into 15, 20 years of conflict where major water decisions are going to be made by judges who live far away from this basin with limited expertise, that’s a terrible outcome because we’ll end up spending tens of millions of dollars fighting each other instead of tens of millions of dollars building desalination plants and water recycling and water conservation.

Nancy Caywood still owes $20,000 a year in water assessments, even though she hasn’t received a drop in months. She says when farms can’t produce, the impact can reach all of us: tighter food supplies, greater reliance on foreign imports and higher costs.

Scott: Does the government need to do more?

Nancy Caywood: I think they need to pay attention to what’s going on because we’re losing farmland so fast, and it’s not just in Arizona; it’s everywhere. So we’re losing all of this land to growth, and all of a sudden they’re not going to have meals on the table that are from the United States. And they’re going to be eating things that they don’t know how safe they are and that didn’t come from here. And so yes, I do think the government needs to pay attention, and they need to figure out a way to help farmers stay in business.

In the meantime, they stare at the sky, hoping for a helping hand from above.

RECENT POSTS

TAGS

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top